Starbucks Faces Lawsuit Over Misleading “Sugar-Free” Drink Claims

Date:

When you order a pumpkin spice latte or caramel macchiato from Starbucks, you likely have a good understanding of the sugar content in those drinks.

However, what should you anticipate when requesting a drink that’s advertised as “sugar-free”?

This inquiry forms the basis of a proposed class action lawsuit in the U.S. alleging that the coffee giant misrepresented eight protein drinks as “sugar-free,” even though they actually contain between 13 and 21 grams of sugar per venti serving due to the natural sugars found in milk.

Filed on Friday in a federal court in Seattle and reviewed by CBC News, the lawsuit accuses Starbucks of attempting to exploit “the protein trend” and the dietary preferences of its customers.

“By labeling its drinks as ‘Sugar-Free,’ Starbucks is making a specific, measurable, and verifiable assertion about the composition of these beverages. Consumers depend on such claims when making purchasing decisions,” the lawsuit states.

“A venti Sugar-Free Caramel Protein Matcha contains approximately 21 grams of sugar, which is roughly equivalent to five teaspoons of sugar. This amount is nearly comparable to that found in a standard Kit Kat bar.”

An image that says sugar-free protein vanilla latte, with an image of a hand holding a drink.

An Instagram post by Starbucks dated Oct. 23, 2025, promoting some protein beverages as sugar-free. (@Starbucks/Instagram)

A representative from Starbucks informed CBC News on Wednesday that they consider the claims made in the lawsuit to be “without merit.”

“Starbucks has always provided clear and consistent information regarding its protein beverages, sugar-free alternatives, customization options, and nutritional content … and we are prepared to defend ourselves vigorously,” the representative stated.

So, are the beverages actually sugar-free? Is the labeling deceptive? Does this apply only to drinks in the U.S., or does it extend to Canada as well?

Let’s examine the lawsuit more closely and what we currently know.

Which drinks are being referred to?

The lawsuit identifies eight protein beverages that Starbucks categorizes as sugar-free:

  • Sugar-free vanilla protein latte.
  • Sugar-free caramel protein latte.
  • Sugar-free vanilla protein matcha.
  • Sugar-free caramel protein matcha.
  • Iced sugar-free vanilla protein latte.
  • Iced sugar-free caramel protein latte.
  • Iced sugar-free vanilla protein matcha.
  • Iced sugar-free caramel protein matcha.

All of these options can be found on both the U.S. and Starbucks Canada websites under the “protein beverages” category. Even though these drinks are listed under “no added sugar options,” they currently carry “sugar-free” in their titles.

Starbucks introduced these drinks in September 2025, citing data that indicates “71 percent of Canadian consumers are looking to increase their protein intake.” A press release at that time stated that the new protein beverages would be “offered unsweetened or sugar-free and aimed at customers wanting to enhance their protein consumption.”

WATCH | Coffee chains cash in on protein craze:

Coffee chains look to cash in on protein’s popularity

September 2, 2025|

Duration

2:01

Starbucks is set to follow Tim Hortons in offering more protein in its coffee drinks, a trend experts suggest may be more about profit margins than customer health.

Are they truly sugar-free?

No, each of these beverages contains sugar, ranging from 13 to 21 grams for a venti-size serving. At the upper end, this is roughly equivalent to the sugar content found in a Kit Kat or Coffee Crisp bar, according to Health Canada.

When checking the individual drinks on the Starbucks website, the nutritional details for each “sugar-free” protein beverage are provided, including sugar grams per size. For example, a venti iced sugar-free vanilla protein latte has 13 grams of sugar, while a venti sugar-free caramel protein matcha includes 21 grams of sugar.

As noted in the lawsuit, “all the sugar-free products contain milk, which has lactose, a naturally occurring sugar.”

What’s the problem with natural sugar?

The concern lies not with the source of the sugar but with the “sugar-free” labeling, as per the lawsuit.

“Even though Starbucks is aware that Sugar-Free products contain milk, which has lactose, a type of sugar, and even classifies this lactose as sugar, it still refers to these beverages as ‘Sugar-Free,'” the lawsuit asserts.

“Starbucks designates these beverages as ‘Sugar-Free’ because it understands that consumers depend on such representations when making their purchasing choices.”

What consumer protection laws apply?

According to U.S. federal regulations, Starbucks is prohibited from labeling beverages as “sugar-free” if they contain more than 0.5 grams of sugar per 12-ounce serving, as stated in the complaint. This holds true even if the sugar is derived from milk.

In Canada, something can only be labeled as sugar-free if it contains less than 0.5 grams of sugars per reference amount and serving of the specified size, based on the Food and Drug Regulations.

WATCH | Are the new labels on Canadian foods visible enough?:

Are the new labels on high fat, sugar and sodium foods visible enough?

January 1|

Duration

1:59

New nutrition symbols are now mandatory for many packaged goods in Canada. They indicate if the product is high in saturated fat, sugars or sodium. But some experts worry they’re not obvious enough to make a difference.

In both the U.S. and Canada, there is a clear distinction between labeling something as “sugar-free,” as Starbucks has done with its protein drinks, and stating that it has “no added sugars,” which is how Starbucks also categorizes the drinks in their nutritional details due to the use of sugar-free syrups.

Lactose is identified as a sugar in both Canada and the U.S.

Food manufacturers often face lawsuits for alleged misleading advertising, including numerous recent cases challenging “sugar-free” or “zero sugar” claims for products that incorporate a sugar substitute known as allulose.

What are the next steps?

The complaint seeks unspecified damages for false advertising and breaches of various state consumer protection statutes. It also aims to classify the lawsuit as a class action and requests a jury trial “on all triable issues.”

This lawsuit was initiated on behalf of three individual consumers who purchased Starbucks’s sugar-free protein drinks in California, New York, and Washington.

Consumers may avoid sugar for numerous reasons, including health concerns such as diabetes, according to Steve Berman, co-founder and managing partner of the Seattle-based firm that filed the lawsuit, in a press statement.

“For many, mislabeling of this nature is quite significant,” Berman stated.

“Drinking beverages with this level of sugar is akin to consuming a candy bar.”

Source

More like this
Related

EU Softens Stance on Combustion Engine Sales, Aims for Flexibility

The European Union has decided to abandon its initiative...

Alberta’s Bill 13 Could Shield Workers’ Free Speech Outside Work Hours

Workers in regulated professions across Alberta may soon be...

Bear Attack in Cumberland: Residents Urged to Stay Vigilant

Residents are being urged to exercise heightened vigilance by...

Trump Blocks Oil Tankers to Venezuela, Labels Maduro a Terrorist

On Tuesday, U.S. President Donald Trump announced that he...