Airbnb Photos Raise Red Flags: Are Listings Too Good to Be True?

Date:

LISTEN | When Airbnb photos don’t match reality:

Josh Wells, an Iowa college student, was thrilled to visit Montreal for his first journey outside the United States. However, as he browsed through Airbnb listings in search of accommodations, he began to observe some discrepancies.

Many of the property owners featured profile images that Wells suspected were created using artificial intelligence.

“When you see an average person taking a picture with an iPhone, there are usually some imperfections,” Wells shared with the CBC’s Cost of Living. “The AI-generated images just seemed excessively flawless.”

Despite this, Wells continued his search. He was even on the verge of reserving one property when a final inspection of the listing’s photos alerted him to another issue.

He zoomed in on a piece of wall art featuring two halves of faces merged together. The artwork appeared to read “Picasso” at the top. However, in another photo of the same space, captured from a different angle, the artwork looked altered.

“The text appeared all distorted and strange,” he remarked. “I thought, ‘Yeah, this is definitely AI.'”

A composite photo that shows three headshots of a man and two women smiling.

While planning his trip to Montreal, Wells noticed that many Airbnb listings featured exceptionally polished images of hosts, leading him to suspect they were AI-generated. The short-term rentals in the city are governed by strict regulations aimed, in part, at safeguarding the local housing market. (Josh Wells/Reddit)

That was enough to deter Wells from the listing — and eventually from using Airbnb for this trip. With uncertainty about whether the images depicted a real location or an AI-crafted version, he chose to stay at an apartment-style hotel instead.

“The fake profile picture was one issue, but the potential misrepresentation of the actual place where you’re spending a significant amount of money was a definite no for me,” Wells stated.

Wells is not the only traveler questioning the authenticity of images found on Airbnb or similar short-term rental platforms.

In July, an Ottawa family reported that upon arrival at a Toronto Airbnb, their daughter discovered a room that looked markedly different from the images in the listing, which they believed had been altered or generated using AI.

The family provided comparative images illustrating the discrepancies in the room and bathroom. While Airbnb acknowledged that the listing did not correspond with the actual property and issued a refund to the guest, it did not confirm whether AI had been utilized.

As AI technology simplifies photo manipulation, experts warn that travelers may increasingly struggle to ascertain whether Airbnb listings accurately represent reality, raising concerns about consumer trust and protections in Canada.

When a photo makeover goes too far

The rise of free, quick, and user-friendly AI tools makes photo editing more appealing, according to Francis Syms, associate dean in the faculty of applied sciences and technology at Humber Polytechnic in Toronto.

Aside from major AI platforms like ChatGPT, Claude by Anthropic, and Google’s Gemini, numerous websites provide free tools for altering images, noted Syms. For instance, Hugging Face offers thousands of AI tools that allow users to upload and modify photos.

“In just about 10 seconds, you can upload an image to one of these sites and request it to remove blemishes or change the furniture,” he explained. “You can expect to receive the edited image back within 30 to 60 seconds.”

A screen.

Platforms like ChatGPT enable users to quickly and effortlessly edit photos. (Marco Bertorello/AFP via Getty Images)

Identifying when AI editing crosses into misleading territory can be challenging, according to Daniel Guttentag, an associate professor of hospitality and tourism management at the College of Charleston in South Carolina.

“If you add a fake hot tub on the patio, it’s clear that this is a blatant misrepresentation of what the unit offers,” he stated. “However, if you merely tweak the lighting a bit… I think most people would find that acceptable.

“But there’s a significant gray area in between, where it crosses into the realm of ‘Wait, this isn’t what I expected.'”

Guttentag also raised concerns regarding the potential use of AI-altered images to falsely suggest that guests have caused damage to a property, which could trigger compensation claims.

In 2025, a guest from London, U.K., reserved an Airbnb in Manhattan and was accused of inflicting over £12,000 ($22,665) in damages.

She contested the claim after noticing discrepancies in photos of a purportedly damaged coffee table, which she suspected had been digitally altered or produced by AI.

Initially, Airbnb claimed she owed more than £5,000 ($9,444), but later fully refunded her after the incident attracted media attention.

Can you trust what you see online?

For Airbnb guests, the reliance on listing photos to determine which property to book emphasizes the importance of trust, explained Guttentag.

“You can’t try it out beforehand like you would with a pair of shoes,” he stated. “You need to have confidence and trust that it will meet your expectations.”

While AI-altered images may assist hosts in securing bookings in the short term, guests who arrive to find a stark difference from what was advertised may leave unfavorable reviews, Guttentag noted. If individuals feel misled “one too many times,” he cautioned, it could lead them to abandon the platform altogether.

A man wearing a suit smiles at the camera.

Daniel Guttentag serves as an associate professor of hospitality and tourism management at the College of Charleston in South Carolina, with research focuses on Airbnb and artificial intelligence. (Submitted by Daniel Guttentag)

In a statement to CBC News, Airbnb asserts that its policies mandate listings to be “accurately depicted” and that the company may request hosts to eliminate any content utilizing AI or other digital methods to “edit imperfections, conceal damage, add features or attributes not included in a listing, or otherwise materially misrepresent the listing.”

The company also stated that it encourages guests to report misleading listings, and those who discover a property that does not align with its description can reach out to its 24/7 community support team. Under AirCover, Airbnb mentioned, it may assist guests in finding a comparable place or offer a refund if the host cannot resolve the issue.

In August, California’s Artificial Intelligence Transparency Act (CAITA) came into effect, requiring AI-generated images, videos, and audio to include information that aids consumers in identifying whether digital content was created or modified using AI.

A silver robot profile is photographed against a white screen with black text and an orange symbol beside it.

A figurine in front of the logo of the AI assistant “Claude” created by the US artificial intelligence safety and research company Anthropic during a photo session in Paris on February 13, 2026. (Joel Saget/AFP via Getty Images)

Canada has yet to establish AI-specific laws addressing misleading advertising, according to Steve Szentesi, a competition and advertising lawyer based in Toronto. However, he noted that existing regulations could already apply to deceptive AI-generated images.

The federal Competition Act prohibits misleading advertising, regardless of whether the claims are conveyed through text, images, audio, or other media forms. Provincial and territorial consumer protection laws provide similar safeguards.

While AI-generated images are a relatively new phenomenon, Szentesi explained that the core issue is not. Courts have addressed disputes over real estate listings for decades, including cases where property images did not correspond with the actual home or contradicted the descriptions in the listing.

For consumers who believe a short-term rental listing misrepresents a property, Szentesi advises first raising the concern with the rental platform. They may also file a complaint with the Competition Bureau or their provincial or territorial consumer protection agency.

Meanwhile, Syms recommends that prospective bookers look for potential signs of AI-generated images in listing photos, including misaligned door frames, unusual tile lines and countertops, oddly shaped furniture, inconsistent shadows or reflections, and unclear or jumbled text on books or wall art.

Travelers can also utilize tools like Google Lens, he suggested, to find the same image online and verify if it has been sourced from another website instead of depicting the actual property.

For Wells, the experience hasn’t completely dissuaded him from using Airbnb again — he had a positive experience booking through the platform in Kansas City last March. Nevertheless, his search for accommodations in Montreal has made him more cautious, he admitted.

“I am open to using it again, provided there are no fake AI listings involved.”

Source

More like this
Related

Susie Wiles’ Candid Insights on Trump: A ‘Hit Piece’ or Truth?

Susie Wiles, chief of staff to U.S. President Donald...

Canada’s Cannabis Tax Revenue Surpasses $5.4 Billion Since 2018

Since the legalization of recreational cannabis in October 2018,...

Tragic Brampton Fire Claims Two Lives, Four Others in Critical Condition

A tragic house fire in Brampton has resulted in...

Mountain Bluebird Population Plummets 60% in Canada Since 1970

Despite their name, mountain bluebirds are commonly found throughout...